More Hot Air from the Cold North

The blogger who we know affectionately as “Canada’s Million Dollar Man” holds forth on the subject of copyright in Canada in an FAQ that one must reasonably believe he thought important on the subject of “Copyright Reform”. Given the recent activity in Europe, it is well to focus for a moment on who means what […]

What do Canada, Vietnam, China, Russia, Ukraine and Romania have in common? (And, no, it’s not future sites of the Creative Commons Internationale)

In a demonstration of true bipartisanship, the Obama Administration today elevated Canada to the “Priority Watch List” on the U.S. Trade Representative’s “Special 301 Report”. A country is placed on the Priority Watch List if the country’s intellectual policy practices “…have the most onerous or egregious acts, policies, or practices and whose acts, policies, or […]

DOJ Separates the Dirt from the Tech

This just in: According to FT, “The US Department of Justice has begun informal enquiries into at least one aspect of Google’s sweeping settlement of lawsuits from book publishers and authors, according to two people familiar with the discussions.” Oopsie.

The Wrong Tail Redux

I’ve been saying for years what everyone involved with p2p already knew–after Napster it was never about music introduction, it was all about getting away with stealing copies of something the user already knew about. It’s the rough equivalent of going to your local record store (or more commonly to iTunes) and finding out everything […]

Why the Pirate Bay Verdict Does Matter: What Justification for Punishing the Pirate Bay?

There are typically two justifications for punishment: retributive and utilitarian. Legal philosopher John Rawls succinctly summarizes the retributive view: Wrongdoing merits punishment. Society benefits when a person who does wrong suffers punishment in proportion to the depravity of her act irrespective of any of the consequences of punishing her. Failing to punish is a corrosive […]